musicMagpie vs Mazuma — which pays more for your old phone?

musicMagpie vs Mazuma — the basics

Both musicMagpie and Mazuma are among the longest-established and most trusted phone recyclers in the UK. Both are legitimate, both have strong Trustpilot scores, and both offer free postage with fast payment. So which should you choose?

The honest answer is: whichever is paying more for your specific phone today. Prices change daily, and the winner varies by model, condition and storage size. But understanding each company's strengths helps you make the right choice.

musicMagpie — the UK's largest consumer recycler

musicMagpie was founded in 2007 and has grown to become one of the UK's largest consumer tech recyclers by volume. They accept phones, tablets, games consoles, CDs, DVDs and more.

Strengths:

• Very high volume means competitive pricing on popular iPhone and Samsung models
• Fast payment — typically within 24 hours of receiving your device
• PayPal and bank transfer options
• Strong Trustpilot rating with a very large number of verified reviews
• Simple, well-designed selling process
• Also buy non-phone items if you have more to sell

Weaknesses:

• Prices on older or less popular models can be lower than specialists
• Grading can be strict — condition must match what you described

Best for: Selling recent iPhones and Samsung flagships. People who want fast, simple payment.

Mazuma — the price lock specialists

Mazuma has been buying phones since 2006 and is well known for their price lock guarantee — they promise to pay the quoted amount or return your device for free, no questions asked.

Strengths:

• Price lock guarantee — no revised offers once you accept their quote
• Wide device acceptance including older models
• Strong Trustpilot rating
• Competitive on older iPhone models (iPhone 11, 12, 13)
• Payment typically within 1-2 days of receiving your device

Weaknesses:

• Prices on the very latest flagships can be slightly behind musicMagpie
• Less strong on non-phone items

Best for: People who want certainty — no risk of a revised offer. Older iPhone models.

Price comparison — who pays more?

This varies constantly. The only reliable answer comes from comparing live prices at the time you want to sell. Based on observed pricing patterns:

musicMagpie tends to be stronger on: iPhone 15, 16, Samsung S24, S25 — recent popular flagships where high volume drives competitive buying prices.

Mazuma tends to be stronger on: iPhone 13, 12, older Samsung A-range models — where their price lock and specialist positioning pays off.

The price difference for the same phone is usually £5-£20. That is real money worth checking, but neither recycler consistently dominates across every model.

Payment speed comparison

Both are fast by the standards of the UK market:

• musicMagpie — typically 24 hours after receiving your device
• Mazuma — typically 1-2 days after receiving your device

Both offer free postage with a prepaid label and packaging supplied.

Trustpilot scores

Both companies have strong and well-established Trustpilot profiles with hundreds of thousands of verified reviews. Both score above 4.5 on Trustpilot as of 2026. The volume of reviews on both platforms means the scores are reliable signals, not statistical noise.

Which should you choose?

Choose musicMagpie if: You are selling a recent flagship iPhone or Samsung, you want payment within 24 hours, or you have multiple items to sell at once.

Choose Mazuma if: You want the certainty of a price lock guarantee, you are selling an older model, or musicMagpie's quote is lower.

The smartest move: Compare both, plus at least three other recyclers, using GadgetRank. The difference between the best and worst offer for your phone can be £50 or more — and neither musicMagpie nor Mazuma is always the winner.

Compare all recycler prices for your phone now →

See how all the major UK recyclers compare →